For most first-time pilgrims from the USA and Canada, Madinah first is the better order: no Ihram on the plane, two calm days to recover, and Ihram at Dhul-Hulayfah when you are rested.
Makkah first is not wrong — it suits experienced travelers, short trips and some Ramadan and New Year programs — but it asks you to enter Ihram at 35,000 feet and perform Tawaf within hours of a 12-hour flight. Neither order is a religious requirement. Here is every factor that should decide it for you.*
Jeddah → Makkah · ~1–1.5 h*
Jeddah → Madinah · ~4–5 h coach*
Makkah ↔ Madinah train · ~2 h 20 min*
“Which city do we go to first?” is usually the second question a family asks us, right after the price — and it is a better question than most people realize, because the answer decides where you put on Ihram, how tired you are for your Umrah, which airport you fly out of, and how your ten days feel. The geography is simple: Jeddah’s airport is about an hour from Makkah and four to five hours from Madinah; Madinah has its own airport but no regular nonstop flights from North America.* Everything below follows from those two facts.
The Two Itineraries, Side by Side
| Factor | Madinah first | Makkah first |
|---|---|---|
| Arrival | Land in Jeddah in normal clothes; coach 4–5 hours north to Madinah (or fly into Madinah via a one-stop routing) | Land in Jeddah already in Ihram; coach about an hour to Makkah |
| Where you enter Ihram | Dhul-Hulayfah (Abyar Ali), 20 minutes outside Madinah, after a shower at the hotel, on the imam’s cue | On the aircraft, before it crosses the Miqat — announced about an hour before landing; garments on before boarding the final leg |
| When you perform Umrah | Day 5 or 6, rested, after the imam’s preparation sessions in Madinah | Day 1 or 2, within hours of a 12–16 hour journey |
| Jet lag | Absorbed in Madinah’s calmer rhythm before the physical demands of Tawaf and Sa’i | Hits you in the Mataf |
| Intercity transfer | Madinah → Makkah by coach with the Miqat stop (5–6 h) or train (~2 h 20 min plus station transfers) | Makkah → Madinah by coach (5–6 h) or train; no Miqat stop needed |
| Departure airport | Jeddah, about 1.5–2 hours from your Makkah hotel; nonstop home | Madinah, with a one-stop routing home — or a 4–5 hour coach back to Jeddah for the nonstop |
| Emotional arc | Builds: the Prophet’s city, then the Kaaba as the climax | Peaks early; Madinah as the gentle close — many experienced pilgrims love this |
| Best for | First-timers, families with children, elderly parents, anyone on a nonstop from the US | Experienced pilgrims, short trips, Ramadan itineraries that want Makkah last, travelers with one-stop tickets into Jeddah and out of Madinah |
Option A: Madinah First — Why Most Groups Do It This Way
- You fly in normal clothes. Twelve hours from New York with nothing to manage but sleep. No question of whether you crossed the Miqat, no changing in an aircraft lavatory, no cold cabin in two cotton sheets.
- You land and are driven, not tested. The coach from Jeddah to Madinah takes four to five hours*; most people sleep through it and wake up at the hotel. If your routing connects through Istanbul, Doha or Dubai you may land in Madinah directly and skip the coach entirely — see our flights guide.
- Madinah heals the journey. Three or four days of prayer in the Prophet’s Mosque, the Rawdah visit, the ziyarah of Quba and Uhud, meals at fixed times and early nights. By day five the family is on local time and the imam has taught the Umrah twice.
- Ihram at the Miqat, the Prophet’s way. Dhul-Hulayfah is the Miqat the Prophet (peace be upon him) himself used when he set out from Madinah. You shower at the hotel, dress in the lobby with the imam checking the sheets, pray two rak’ahs at the Miqat mosque and make the intention together.
- You perform Umrah as the climax. Arriving in Makkah in the late afternoon, resting an hour, and walking to the Haram as a group after Isha for your first sight of the Kaaba in Ihram — this is the moment people describe for the rest of their lives, and you meet it awake.
- You leave from the near airport. Jeddah is an hour and a half from Makkah and the nonstop flies you home from there. No long transfer on the last day.
Option B: Makkah First — When It Makes Sense
- The Umrah is done early. Some travelers — especially those who have been before — want the obligation-like weight of the Umrah off their shoulders on night one, and then to spend the rest of the trip in relaxed worship. That is a legitimate preference.
- Short trips. On a seven-night program, Makkah first saves the Madinah-to-Makkah Miqat day and puts you in front of the Kaaba faster.
- Ramadan, the last ten nights. Pilgrims who want to be in Makkah for the final nights of Ramadan often go to Madinah first and Makkah last — but those arriving mid-Ramadan for a short stay sometimes do Makkah first to secure their Umrah before the crowds peak. Our own Ramadan departure goes to Madinah first and ends with the last nights in Makkah.
- New Year and holiday timing. Two of our own 2026–27 departures — the New Year programs — run Makkah first, with the Umrah performed on arrival and Madinah as the gentle close of the trip.*
- Ticket geometry. If you are flying one-stop through Istanbul, Doha or Dubai, an “open-jaw” ticket into Jeddah and out of Madinah costs little extra and makes Makkah-first flow naturally: land, Umrah, train to Madinah, fly home from Madinah.
What About Flying Straight into Madinah?
It is a real option, and often the most comfortable one — but not on a nonstop. As of the latest schedules, Saudia is the only airline flying nonstop between the United States and Saudi Arabia, and it lands in Jeddah (and Riyadh), not Madinah; there are no regular nonstop flights from the US or Canada to Madinah.* Turkish Airlines, Qatar Airways, Emirates and others fly into Madinah year-round from their hubs, so a one-stop itinerary can put you in Madinah without the coach, and an open-jaw ticket can bring you home from Jeddah. Whether the extra four to six hours of travel time and a layover with children are worth skipping a four-hour coach is a family-by-family decision; for elderly travelers it often is.
The Religious Question: Does the Order Matter?
No. Visiting Madinah is a beloved Sunnah and a spiritual highlight, but it is not part of Umrah; a pilgrim who never sets foot in Madinah has performed a complete Umrah. Nothing in the Qur’an or Sunnah requires one city before the other, and the four schools of law do not differ on this. What the Sunnah does fix is the Miqat: whichever order you choose, you must enter Ihram before crossing the boundary toward Makkah. Madinah first happens to make that rule effortless, because the coach stops at Dhul-Hulayfah on the way; Makkah first makes it something you must manage on an airplane. That practical difference — not a religious one — is why our imams recommend Madinah first for anyone who has not done this before.
How Hisar Tour Plans It
Of our fourteen published 2026–27 Umrah departures, twelve go to Madinah first and two — the New Year programs — go to Makkah first.* On every Madinah-first group, arrival day has no schedule, the Ihram briefing happens the night before in the hotel, the coach stops at Dhul-Hulayfah with the imam leading the intention, and the Umrah is performed together after Isha on the day we reach Makkah. On the Makkah-first programs, the imam walks the group through Ihram at the departure gate, the flight crew’s Miqat announcement is anticipated on the headsets, and the coach waits at Jeddah to drive the group straight to the hotel and then the Haram. Either way, nobody is left to work out the Miqat alone at row 34.
Not sure which order fits your family?
Tell us who is traveling, your dates and your departure city. We will recommend Madinah first or Makkah first for your group — honestly, including when a one-stop routing into Madinah would serve you better than our nonstop.
See Umrah Packages
WhatsApp +1 201-201-8992
A UAMA community organization · Imam-led groups from New York, Washington, Los Angeles and Toronto
Related: your first Umrah, day by day, the best time of year to go, and the Umrah FAQ for US and Canadian travelers.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is it better to go to Makkah or Madinah first for Umrah?
For first-time pilgrims, families and elderly travelers, Madinah first: you fly in normal clothes, recover from the journey in a calmer city, and enter Ihram rested at Dhul-Hulayfah before traveling to Makkah. Makkah first suits experienced pilgrims, short trips and certain Ramadan or New Year programs. Religiously, either order is valid.
Do I have to visit Madinah to complete Umrah?
No. Umrah consists of Ihram, Tawaf, Sa’i and the haircut, all in Makkah. Visiting the Prophet’s Mosque in Madinah is a highly recommended Sunnah and a highlight of every trip, but it is not a part of Umrah and its order does not affect validity.
Can I fly directly from the USA to Madinah?
Not on a regular nonstop. Saudia’s nonstop US flights land in Jeddah and Riyadh, not Madinah. To arrive in Madinah by air you connect through a hub such as Istanbul, Doha or Dubai. Otherwise you land in Jeddah and travel to Madinah by coach (about 4–5 hours) or by the Haramain train from the airport station.
Where is the Miqat if I fly into Jeddah and go to Makkah first?
On the aircraft. Flights from Europe and the Americas cross the Miqat line — usually the al-Juhfah line — before landing, and crews announce it about an hour out. You must have the Ihram garments on and make the intention before that point. Jeddah itself is inside the boundary, so Ihram cannot be assumed at the airport.
How long does it take to travel between Makkah and Madinah?
About five to six hours by coach including a stop at the Miqat when heading to Makkah, or about two hours twenty minutes station to station on the Haramain High-Speed Train, plus transfers at both ends since the stations are several kilometers from the mosques.
Which order does Hisar Tour use?
Madinah first on twelve of our fourteen published 2026–27 departures; the two New Year programs go to Makkah first. Each departure page states the order, the hotels and the number of nights in each city.
*Flight routings reflect published airline schedules as of August 2026 and change seasonally; verify current routes before booking. Transfer and journey durations are approximate and depend on traffic, season and stops. The departure count reflects Hisar Tour’s published Umrah packages page as of August 2026. Religious points are summarized from the mainstream positions of the four Sunni schools; ask your imam about your own situation. Last reviewed: September 2026.
Last Updated on August 31, 2026
